After a storm, the agent who picks up the phone and knows your policy is worth more than the cheapest premium. We pulled every insurance agency Google lists in Byron Center, MI, checked which ones actually have an address in town, read their reviews, and went through their websites to build this list.
How we chose this list: Insurance agencies are sorted by Google rating weighted by review count. Companies based in Byron Center come first. This list is updated for 2026.
Quick Comparison
| # | Company | Rating | Reviews | Phone |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Farmers Insurance - Tyler Johnson | ★★★★★4.9 | 128 | (616) 805-3853 |
| 2 | Compass Insurance Agency | ★★★★★5.0 | 23 | (616) 965-3747 |
| 3 | Medina Insurance Agency | ★★★★★5.0 | 22 | (313) 704-3398 |
| 4 | Troy Peterson - State Farm Insurance Agent | ★★★★★4.8 | 265 | (616) 534-8669 |
| 5 | Quakkelaar Insurance Agency | ★★★★★5.0 | 11 | (616) 583-8300 |
| 6 | Highstreet - Ottawa Kent - Byron Center | ★★★★★4.7 | 54 | (616) 797-3404 |
| 7 | Aaron Andrews: Allstate Insurance | ★★★★★4.7 | 22 | (616) 878-9250 |
Farmers Insurance - Tyler Johnson
Address: 8233 Byron Center Ave SW L, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 805-3853
Website: agents.farmers.com
Tyler Johnson runs a Farmers Insurance office at 8233 Byron Ctr Ave SW, Suite L, in Byron Center. The office writes auto, home, renters, condo and life coverage. Reviewers mention local agents who are friendly, responsive and quick to help. One customer says the office saved them a significant amount on three cars and a homeowners policy. Another describes combining renters, motorcycle and auto policies for a lower price. Several reviewers also say the staff are polite and respect that people want help on their own terms, without pushy cold calls. If you need coverage for farm or commercial equipment, one reviewer mentions an efficient process insuring a new side by side.
What stands out:
- Online quotes with saved quote retrieval
- Evening and weekend appointments available by request
- Reviewers mention large bundle discounts
- Business and umbrella policies listed on website
Compass Insurance Agency
Address: 8535 Byron Commerce Dr SW Ste B, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 965-3747
Website: compass-insurance-agency.com
In Byron Center, Compass Insurance Agency runs a local branch that reviewers describe as helpful and friendly. One customer says the team has handled their home, auto and boat policies for seven years and went out of its way during the few claims they filed. Other reviewers say an agent spent real time finding the right home and auto plan for their family, then kept them updated until everything was finished. A reviewer who moved to Grand Rapids mentions an easy, responsive process for homeowners coverage at a good price. Several customers say they have recommended the branch to family and friends.
What stands out:
- Byron Center branch of Compass Insurance
- Reviewers mention knowledgeable, friendly staff
- Boat policies mentioned alongside home and auto
- Responsive service for new homeowners
Medina Insurance Agency
Address: 8650 Byron Center Ave SW ste25, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (313) 704-3398
Website: medina-insurance.com
Medina Insurance Agency is in Byron Center and offers auto, home, business and life insurance. The website describes the agency as one stop for these needs and lets you request a quote. Car insurance comes up often in reviews. Reviewers say the agent explained their options clearly, made the process smooth, and sent a copy of the policy the same day. Others mention personal attention on home and auto policies and real effort to find affordable prices. Several customers describe getting insured quickly and conveniently, with good communication throughout.
What stands out:
- Located in Byron Center
- Quote requests through the agency website
- Renters coverage listed among services
- Reviewers mention patient, knowledgeable agents
Troy Peterson - State Farm Insurance Agent
Address: 2499 84th St SW Ste B, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 534-8669
Website: troyinsuresmi.com
Troy Peterson's State Farm office in Byron Center sells car, home and life insurance. The website also publishes seasonal home tips, such as testing smoke alarms and carbon monoxide detectors in October. Many reviewers had switched from other carriers and say the office helped them lower their rates. They describe consistent follow up that never felt pushy, patience with questions, and clear explanations of what each policy would add compared with their current coverage. One reviewer had been with another company since 1995 and mentions how easy the change felt. Others say they plan to pass the office's name to friends and family.
What stands out:
- State Farm agency in Byron Center
- Free quotes by phone at (616) 534-8669
- Reviewers mention savings on auto policies
- Business insurance listed on the website
Quakkelaar Insurance Agency
Address: 1400 84th St SW, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 583-8300
Website: farmbureauinsurance-mi.com
Quakkelaar Insurance Agency is a Michigan Farm Bureau agency in Byron Center. Reviewers mention auto, home and life insurance handled through the office. One couple, referred by a local businessman in 2019, says they have been satisfied with the knowledge, professionalism and value they found there. Reviewers describe the agency as easy to reach and quick to answer questions. Others point to helpful guidance through their insurance needs and pricing they were very happy with. If you want one office to handle several policies, reviewers say this agency has done that for them.
What stands out:
- Michigan Farm Bureau Insurance agency
- Located in Byron Center
- Umbrella policies mentioned by reviewers
- Reviewers mention strong knowledge of insurance products
Highstreet - Ottawa Kent - Byron Center
Address: 7885 Byron Center Ave SW, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 797-3404
Website: ottawakent.com
Part of Highstreet Insurance & Financial Services, this Ottawa Kent office is in Byron Center. The agency's website lists life and business insurance, along with claims support. Reviewers describe long relationships, with one family saying they have been clients for almost 38 years and keep their home, vehicle and life policies there. Several say the agency kept them informed about available savings and reviewed their coverage as prices rose. Others mention personal service while working through claims. Service is a common theme, with one reviewer saying it turned out even better than the pricing that first drew them in.
What stands out:
- Located in Byron Center
- Home, auto and business coverage listed
- Reviewers mention low rates for first time buyers
- Help with title and license transfers
Aaron Andrews: Allstate Insurance
Address: 8373 Merton Ave SW B, Byron Center, MI 49315
Phone: (616) 878-9250
Website: agents.allstate.com
Aaron Andrews runs an Allstate office in Byron Center. Reviewers describe the agent as professional and knowledgeable, and say he took time to explain coverage options so they could decide without feeling rushed or pressured. One homeowner, shopping for new coverage after their old insurer left the Michigan market, mentions excellent service from the office. A couple who moved from Florida say they felt welcomed, got insight on which policies they needed, and even received local tips about the area. Reviewers also mention friendly staff and prompt, thorough answers to their questions.
What stands out:
- Allstate agency located in Byron Center
- Homeowners insurance quotes for Michigan residents
- Reviewers mention clear explanations of coverage
- Welcoming office for people new to the area
How We Built This List
- Google reviews and ratings pulled via the Google Places API on 2026-11-16, sorted by rating weighted by review count.
- Location. Companies with an address in Byron Center, MI rank ahead of companies based nearby.
- Michigan producer license, verified on the DIFS lookup.
- Google rating weighted by review count.
- Carriers represented: captive or independent.
- Claims support described on their site.
- Website review for services offered, years in business and any licenses or credentials the company publishes.
Licensing in Michigan: Michigan insurance agents are licensed by the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). Captive agents sell one carrier; independent agents quote several. Check the license on the DIFS lookup.
Disclosure: Roofing Army is a roofing company. We do not do this kind of work, we have no business relationship with the companies above, and nobody paid to be listed. We built this list because our customers in Byron Center ask us who to call. Verify licenses and get more than one quote.
Need a Roofer in Byron Center, MI?
We meet adjusters on site for storm claims and document what is actually damaged. A good agent makes that process faster. Roofing Army inspects roofs in Byron Center for free, quotes five options at different price points, and takes no deposit until the job is done.
Comparing roofers? See the best roofing companies in Byron Center. Budgeting? See what a roof replacement costs in Byron Center, with real prices from our published jobs.
More Byron Center Rankings
- Best Roofing Companies in Byron Center, MI
- Best Electricians in Byron Center, MI
- Best Gutter Companies in Byron Center, MI
- Best Home Inspectors in Byron Center, MI
- Best HVAC Companies in Byron Center, MI
- Best Landscapers in Byron Center, MI
- Best House Painters in Byron Center, MI
- Best Plumbers in Byron Center, MI
- Best Realtors in Byron Center, MI
- Best Siding Companies in Byron Center, MI
- Best Tree Services in Byron Center, MI
- Best Window Replacement Companies in Byron Center, MI
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there an insurance agency based in Byron Center?
Yes. All seven agencies on this list are in Byron Center: Farmers Insurance with Tyler Johnson, Compass Insurance Agency, Medina Insurance Agency, Troy Peterson's State Farm office, Quakkelaar Insurance Agency, the Highstreet Ottawa Kent office and Aaron Andrews with Allstate. That gives you Farmers, State Farm, Allstate and Michigan Farm Bureau offices plus local agencies to compare without leaving town.
Does homeowners insurance cover roof replacement in Michigan?
It depends on your policy and the cause of the damage. Damage from a sudden event such as a storm is often covered, while wear from age usually is not. Policies also differ on whether they pay replacement cost or actual cash value for an older roof. Ask your agent to explain your roof coverage before you need it. We meet adjusters on site for storm claims and document what is actually damaged, and a good agent makes that process faster.
Captive or independent agent: which is better?
Neither is better for everyone. Captive agents sell one carrier and know that company's products well. Independent agents quote several carriers, which can make comparing prices easier. Either way, Michigan insurance agents are licensed by the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). Before you buy a policy, check the agent's license on the DIFS lookup.
Does Roofing Army help with insurance claims?
No. Roofing Army does roofing only and does not sell insurance or manage claims. Your agent and carrier handle the claim itself. What we can do is inspect your roof for free in Byron Center, meet the adjuster on site after a storm, and document what is actually damaged so the claim reflects the real condition of your roof.




