Best Insurance Agents in Novi, MI (2026)

Steve Karagatsoulis runs a State Farm office in Novi that writes home, auto, life and business insurance. Reviewers describe staff who follow up, answer questions without hesitation and keep customers updated at each step. One customer mentions a staff member staying past closing time to finish a quote. Another describes new car policies prepared and sent to the dealer quickly. Because it is a State Farm agency, the quotes come from State Farm. If you want one carrier and a local office to call, this is a simple option to start with.

Based in Novi, Highstreet Autumn Insurance & Benefits covers personal, group benefits and commercial lines. On the personal side, the website lists homeowners, auto, life, umbrella, health and disability coverage. Employers can find group medical, dental, vision and life plans. For businesses, it lists commercial property, general liability, workers compensation, business auto and construction bonding. Reviewers include long-time clients, some for more than ten years, and several business owners. They mention quick replies to phone calls, thorough explanations of their needs and a team that stays on top of the details for companies with more than one business to insure.

J & J Insurance Managers is a Novi agency that calls itself a commercial insurance specialist. The website lists general liability, business interruption, commercial property, commercial auto and workers compensation coverage, plus insurance consulting. Home and auto policies also appear among its services. Reviewers say coverage was explained in plain language, with options that matched their needs and budget. One business owner mentions getting a van and a shop under a single policy, which made things simpler. Others describe the agent shopping around for a competitive quote and handling the documentation efficiently.

This Novi office writes insurance through Michigan Farm Bureau. Jason Levy says on his website that he lives and works in the area. Home options include homeowners, condo, renters, mobile home, Lake Estate and Country Estate policies. He also writes personal auto, umbrella, life, business and workers compensation coverage. Reviewers mention sitting down to review auto and home coverage and making sure they were not paying for more than they needed. Others describe patient answers to many questions, quick follow-up and savings over a previous carrier. One reviewer used the agency to insure a country club.

The Nas Agency is a AAA Insurance office in Novi. Its listing sits on the AAA agent locator, which gives few details, so the reviews tell most of the story. Reviewers mostly describe help with auto insurance. They mention an agent who explained options, answered every question and found coverage that fit their needs. Several say the process felt easy and stress-free, and that staff were patient and respectful. One reviewer, a college student, describes moving from an expensive policy to one they could afford. If auto coverage is your main concern, this office is worth a call.

Tom Deedler's State Farm agency is in Novi, and its website names Walled Lake, Wixom, New Hudson, Commerce Township, Harland and South Lyon as other areas it serves. The office offers free quotes on home, life and auto insurance and also lists business coverage. According to the website, the team is licensed and starts with listening. Reviewers mention auto, home and renters policies explained clearly, without feeling rushed. Several say they got better coverage at a lower rate than before. One customer mentions check-in calls from the agent during the year.

Melanie Fishell works out of the Comparion Insurance Agency office in Novi. The office has licensed agents for auto, home, pet and life insurance and access to multiple carriers, so quotes can come from more than one company. Reviewers describe her as proactive, patient and easy to reach by call or text. One family says she updated their policies to add coverage while lowering overall premiums. A client of eight years mentions help with both policy updates and claims. Others note how she simplified policy details and explained each step clearly.