Roof Replacement & Repairs
Call248-326-2020
roofing army logo
CallText
City Rankings

Best Insurance Agents in Grand Rapids, MI (2026)

By Aaron Scott|5 min read||Grand Rapids, MI

After a storm, the agent who picks up the phone and knows your policy is worth more than the cheapest premium. We pulled every insurance agency Google lists in Grand Rapids, MI, checked which ones actually have an address in town, read their reviews, and went through their websites to build this list.

How we chose this list: Insurance agencies are sorted by Google rating weighted by review count. Companies based in Grand Rapids come first. This list is updated for 2026.

Quick Comparison

#CompanyRatingReviewsPhone
1Boer Insurance Group★★★★★5.0598(616) 363-7766
2Warsen Insurance Agency, Inc.★★★★★5.0210(616) 455-7510
3Insurance Advantage Agency★★★★★5.0179(616) 458-2929
4Ryan Foerch at Comparion Insurance Agency★★★★★5.0113(616) 432-5011
5My Policy Shop Insurance Agency★★★★★5.082(616) 914-4070
6Insurance Resource of Michigan★★★★★5.069(888) 467-7301
7The Brouwers Agency, LLC★★★★★4.9959(616) 891-0123
#1

Boer Insurance Group

★★★★★5.0(598 reviews)

Address: 625 Kenmoor Ave SE Ste. 204, Grand Rapids, MI 49546

Phone: (616) 363-7766

Website: boerinsurance.com

In business since: 1917

Licenses and credentials: Family owned

Boer Insurance Group is a third generation, family owned agency in Grand Rapids. It was founded in 1917, and the firm says it has managed home, auto and umbrella coverage for clients for over 100 years. As an independent agency, it also writes business insurance. Reviewers mention switching from larger carriers and saving money compared to their previous provider. Several describe quick replies to emails and calls about pricing and coverage options. Others say the agent reviewed their home and assets before making recommendations. If you want a long established local office that explains its choices, this is a good place to start.

What stands out:

  • Founded in 1917 in Grand Rapids
  • Third generation, family owned business
  • Home, auto, umbrella and business coverage
  • Reviewers mention savings over previous providers
#2

Warsen Insurance Agency, Inc.

★★★★★5.0(210 reviews)

Address: 6700 Division Ave S, Grand Rapids, MI 49548

Phone: (616) 455-7510

Website: warsenins.com

Based in Grand Rapids, Warsen Insurance Agency, Inc. works as an independent agent, so it can quote with a variety of insurance companies. The agency names Michigan Insurance Company among the carriers it works with and highlights claims service and support after an accident. It also handles business insurance. Reviewers mention help with auto and homeowners policies, and one family says the agency guided them through Medicare supplemental and advantage plans after retirement. Many describe the staff as responsive, knowledgeable and quick to answer questions. Some reviewers say they have worked with the agency for years, and one family for over four decades.

What stands out:

  • Independent agent quoting multiple insurance companies
  • Works with Michigan Insurance Company
  • Business insurance and claims support
  • Reviewers mention help with Medicare plans
#3

Insurance Advantage Agency

★★★★★5.0(179 reviews)

Address: 5234 Plainfield Ave NE Ste c, Grand Rapids, MI 49525

Phone: (616) 458-2929

Website: myrockstaragent.com

This Grand Rapids agency offers auto, home, business, life and pet insurance, and it lists partner carriers on its website. Insurance Advantage Agency says it serves individuals, families and businesses in Grand Rapids and across Michigan. Reviewers describe switching their home and auto policies with little effort and getting better coverage for a lower overall premium. Several say they use the agency for both business and personal insurance. Others mention clear explanations of their options and help finding good rates. For anyone weighing a broker against buying coverage directly, reviewers say having someone manage their insurance made things easier.

What stands out:

  • Auto, home, business, life and pet insurance
  • Works with multiple partner carriers
  • Serves Grand Rapids and all of Michigan
  • Reviewers mention simple, stress free policy switching
#4

Ryan Foerch at Comparion Insurance Agency

★★★★★5.0(113 reviews)

Address: 4362 Cascade Rd SE #110, Grand Rapids, MI 49546

Phone: (616) 432-5011

Website: comparioninsurance.com

Ryan Foerch has worked as a sales representative with Liberty Mutual since March 2001. He recently moved to Comparion Insurance Agency, a Liberty Mutual company, so he can offer more options. His Grand Rapids office handles home, auto, life, business and umbrella coverage. He holds a business degree from Taylor University. Reviewers say he explains coverage in plain language and recommends what is needed without pressure on optional products. Many mention that he returns calls and emails quickly. One reviewer notes that he compared several companies to find a good deal and worked on a Friday evening to finish the job.

What stands out:

  • Liberty Mutual sales representative since March 2001
  • Now with Comparion Insurance Agency
  • Home, auto, life, business and umbrella coverage
  • Reviewers mention no pressure, plain explanations
#5

My Policy Shop Insurance Agency

★★★★★5.0(82 reviews)

Address: 3333 Evergreen Dr NE Ste 220, Grand Rapids, MI 49525

Phone: (616) 914-4070

Website: mypolicyshop.com

Health and Medicare coverage are a large part of the work at My Policy Shop Insurance Agency, a Grand Rapids independent agency. Its website lists health insurance, Medicare, life insurance, long term care and annuities, along with a prescription drug lookup form and educational Medicare videos. The agency also lists the carriers it represents and offers online quotes and enrollment. Reviewers describe help changing Medicare Advantage plans, including checks on doctors and drug coverage. Several say the agent explains complex topics with patience. One reviewer who lives in Florida says the agency has served them well from Michigan.

What stands out:

  • Medicare, health, life and long term care plans
  • Annuities and a prescription drug lookup form
  • Independent agency representing multiple carriers
  • Reviewers mention patient, clear explanations
#6

Insurance Resource of Michigan

★★★★★5.0(69 reviews)

Address: 3000 E Beltline Ave NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49525

Phone: (888) 467-7301

Website: insuranceresourceagency.com

In Grand Rapids, Insurance Resource of Michigan covers personal and business insurance. On the personal side, the agency insures homes, autos, umbrella policies and recreational vehicles. It also helps businesses find and customize coverage. The website includes a real estate agent finder and a section about BHHS, and reviewers mention the agency working with real estate clients during transactions. Customers describe coverage for home, auto, boat and renter's insurance. Reviewers say the agent listens first, recommends changes without pushing, and runs quotes through a variety of carriers. Several have stayed with the agency for many years.

What stands out:

  • Home, auto, umbrella and recreational vehicle coverage
  • Business insurance customized to each company
  • Reviewers mention quotes from several carriers
  • Real estate agent finder on its website
#7

The Brouwers Agency, LLC

★★★★★4.9(959 reviews)

Address: 1925 Breton Rd SE Ste 110, Grand Rapids, MI 49506

Phone: (616) 891-0123

Website: brouwersagency.com

Located at 1925 Breton Rd SE in Grand Rapids, The Brouwers Agency, LLC is an independent insurance agency. It writes home, auto and business coverage, offers Medicare help, and runs a private client group. Clients can start a claim or a quote on its website, and the agency has a risk avoidance section covering water shutoff devices. Reviewers describe agents going through homeowners coverage item by item instead of simply selling a policy. First time home buyers say the process was explained clearly. One reviewer mentions a comparative analysis of existing policies that included a video walkthrough.

What stands out:

  • Independent agency working with multiple carriers
  • Online claim and quote requests
  • Private client group and Medicare options
  • Reviewers mention better deductibles and premiums

How We Built This List

  • Google reviews and ratings pulled via the Google Places API on 2026-11-17, sorted by rating weighted by review count.
  • Location. Companies with an address in Grand Rapids, MI rank ahead of companies based nearby.
  • Michigan producer license, verified on the DIFS lookup.
  • Google rating weighted by review count.
  • Carriers represented: captive or independent.
  • Claims support described on their site.
  • Website review for services offered, years in business and any licenses or credentials the company publishes.

Licensing in Michigan: Michigan insurance agents are licensed by the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). Captive agents sell one carrier; independent agents quote several. Check the license on the DIFS lookup.

Disclosure: Roofing Army is a roofing company. We do not do this kind of work, we have no business relationship with the companies above, and nobody paid to be listed. We built this list because our customers in Grand Rapids ask us who to call. Verify licenses and get more than one quote.

Need a Roofer in Grand Rapids, MI?

We meet adjusters on site for storm claims and document what is actually damaged. A good agent makes that process faster. Roofing Army inspects roofs in Grand Rapids for free, quotes five options at different price points, and takes no deposit until the job is done.

Grand Rapids roofing services →

Comparing roofers? See the best roofing companies in Grand Rapids. Budgeting? See what a roof replacement costs in Grand Rapids, with real prices from our published jobs.

More Grand Rapids Rankings

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there an insurance agency based in Grand Rapids?

Yes. All seven agencies on this list are based in Grand Rapids: Boer Insurance Group, Warsen Insurance Agency, Inc., Insurance Advantage Agency, Ryan Foerch at Comparion Insurance Agency, My Policy Shop Insurance Agency, Insurance Resource of Michigan and The Brouwers Agency, LLC. They range from independent agencies that quote several carriers to an agent with a Liberty Mutual company, so you can pick the setup that fits your needs.

Does homeowners insurance cover roof replacement in Michigan?

It depends on your policy and the cause of the damage. Homeowners policies generally respond to sudden damage, such as a storm, rather than wear from age. Read your policy and ask your agent how roof claims are settled before you need one. Roofing Army meets adjusters on site for storm claims and documents what is actually damaged. A good agent makes that process faster.

Captive or independent agent: which is better?

Michigan insurance agents are licensed by the Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS). Captive agents sell one carrier, while independent agents quote several. Neither is better for everyone. A captive agent knows one company's products well. An independent agent can compare prices and coverage across carriers. Whichever you choose, check the agent's license on the DIFS lookup before you buy a policy.

Does Roofing Army help with insurance claims?

No. Roofing Army does roofing only and is not an insurance agency, so we do not sell policies or handle claims. What we do is meet adjusters on site for storm claims and document what is actually damaged on your roof. We also inspect roofs for free in Grand Rapids. For coverage questions, talk to a licensed insurance agent, such as one of the agencies listed above.

About the Author

Aaron Scott, Owner, Licensed Residential Builder

20+ years in the home service industry. Licensed residential builder in Michigan. Owner of Roofing Army with offices in Oxford, Ferndale, Rochester Hills, Plymouth, and Jenison.

Work With Michigan's Top Roofing Company

Get a free in-home quote.