Best Insurance Agents in Oxford, MI (2026)

Best Senior Health Plans is an Oxford agency built around Medicare guidance. Its website walks through Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage and enrollment at 65, with a glossary and other resources for people new to the system. Beyond Medicare, it lists copay protection plans, ACA Marketplace insurance for families and life insurance. Reviewers mention an agent who is patient and knowledgeable, and who takes time to help seniors through a process that can feel confusing. Several first met the agency at an informative presentation and felt comfortable asking for help afterward. This is a good fit if your questions are about health coverage rather than home or auto.

From his State Farm office in Oxford, Nick Horvath serves the town and nearby parts of Oakland County. As a State Farm agent, he quotes that one carrier rather than shopping several. Reviewers say the team takes time to explain each choice, so they know what their policy covers and where it could be improved. One customer of more than ten years says filed claims have always been processed without trouble. Another picked the agency after comparing several providers and mentions a competitive price. If a storm ever damages the roof, an agent who has already explained the coverage makes the claim easier to start.

In Oxford, Curtis Insurance Agency is known among reviewers for patient explanations. Several describe an agent who walks through the differences between policies and makes sure they understand what each part of their coverage does. One reviewer notes the agent was honest about the premium compared with the coverage being offered. Others mention fast replies to questions, even when they had many of them, and close attention to detail. A friend's referral led another customer to request a quote at renewal, and that customer left pleased. Since no website details were available, ask the office directly which carriers and policy types it offers.

Community Insurance Center works as an independent agency, which means it can compare policies from more than one company. Personal lines include home, auto and condo coverage. On the business side, the website lists business auto, commercial umbrella and cyber liability, plus programs for carpenters, churches and non-profits. Reviewers describe staff who answer emails quickly and update policies as needed. One customer says a quick review of their policy saved more than $1,300. Others mention help buying a first home and getting coverage in place to build a new one. For homeowners who want several quotes side by side, an independent office like this is a practical place to start.

Working out of Oxford, Melisa Counelis and her team write a wide range of personal policies. The website lists homeowners, condo, renters and mobile home coverage, along with personal auto, specialty auto, recreation and personal umbrella insurance. Reviewers mention a careful look at individual needs and savings on house and auto rates. One restaurant owner says she explained everything clearly and made the setup smooth. Another reviewer points out that she also handles mortgage protection and life insurance. The site also features Ting, a program to help prevent electrical fires, which homeowners can ask about.

Angela McConnell has a State Farm office in Oxford, and her website says customer relationships built over many years are her favorite part of the job. Reviews back that up: several customers say they have stayed with the office for close to 20 years. Reviewers describe a staff that is knowledgeable, quick to answer questions and friendly. One says the team handles both personal and business policies. Others describe the office as inviting and say it feels like family. Because it is a State Farm agency, quotes come from that one carrier. That steady relationship can help when you need to file a claim after storm damage.

No website was available for Rich Dagenais Insurance, so this profile draws on what customers say. One reviewer reports saving hundreds of dollars a year with an umbrella insurance option covering both a home and a farm. The other reviews are brief and positive, and one simply calls it a great insurance agent. Since the agency's carriers and policy list are not published, call and ask which companies it represents and whether it can quote home, auto and umbrella coverage together. Bringing your current declarations page to that first call makes comparing easier.